Federal Appeals Court Rules NLRB Restrictions on Removal are Unconstitutional

by Matt Bruenig, Jacobin [Excerpts] https://portside.org/2025-08-24/fifth-circuit-ruled-nlrb-unconstitutional

For the last year or so, federal district court judges in the Fifth Circuit have been enjoining the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) from processing unfair labor practice charges against employers in Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi. These decisions are all [based on] the “unitary executive” theory popular in conservative legal circles. The legal argument goes as follows:

Article II of the US Constitution requires that the president “shall take Care that the Laws be faithfully executed.” The president cannot do so with respect to the NLRB because the NLRB members and administrative law judges (ALJs) are too difficult to fire. Thus, the NLRB’s current structure is unconstitutional and it would cause irreparable harm to these employers to be subject to NLRB administrative processes.

Three of these district court cases were consolidated into an appeal that recently went before the Fifth Circuit. Unsurprisingly, the Fifth Circuit, which is dominated by conservatives, endorsed this particular legal theory and upheld the district court decisions enjoining the NLRB from processing unfair labor practice charges against the involved employers.

The Supreme Court is going to decide on the relevant legal issue in the near future, whether upon appeal of this Fifth Circuit decision or upon the appeal of Wilcox v. Trump, which is currently making its way through the DC Circuit. The Supreme Court has strongly signaled that once it has a chance to do so, it will rule that the removal protections for NLRB judges and NLRB members are unconstitutional under the theory outlined above.

Based on how the court has handled recent similar cases, the Supreme Court will most likely remedy this problem by striking down the removal protections while otherwise leaving the NLRB intact and operational. So at some point in the next year or two, it will become the case that the president at his discretion can fire NLRB members and NLRB Admin Law Judges. [C-L note: Replacements are likely to be less likely to initiate proceedings and more likely to find for the companies.]

The US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit has affirmed preliminary injunctions halting NLRB proceedings against three employers: SpaceX, Energy Transfer, and Findhelp. The consolidated case centered on constitutional challenges to the removal protections for NLRB ALJs and board members.

Musk’s Space X and the others each filed suit in different federal district courts challenging unfair labor practice hearings by questioning the constitutionality of the NLRB’s structure — specifically, the “dual for-cause removal protections” shielding both board members and ALJs from presidential removal. The district courts granted preliminary injunctions halting the NLRB proceedings. [C-L note: Musk’s challenge is understood to threaten the underlying Wagner Act, dating back to the New Deal.]

Board Member Removal Protections

Regarding NLRB board members, who can be removed only “for neglect of duty or malfeasance in office,” the court engaged in a nuanced analysis of whether the Humphrey’s Executor exception applies. The court concluded that the NLRB differs from agencies like the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) in critical ways:

NLRB board members “wield substantial executive power” through their administrative, policymaking, and prosecutorial functions. Unlike the FTC, the NLRB lacks statutory party-balancing requirements, allowing a president to appoint four of five members from his own party. The appellate court agreed that being subjected to a proceeding by an unconstitutionally structured agency constitutes irreparable harm in itself, without requiring proof of specific outcome differences. The majority rejected the NLRB’s argument for retrospective relief from a final agency action (where a causal link showing that the ruling caused harm is required). The court opted for prospective relief from an ongoing unconstitutional proceeding (holding that the process itself is the injury). Finding that the employers demonstrated likelihood of success on the merits, irreparable harm, and that the balance of equities favored relief, the Fifth Circuit affirmed the preliminary injunctions against the NLRB proceedings in all three cases.

Matt Bruenig is the founder of People’s Policy Project.

If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment or subscribing to the RSS feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader.